Will your cyber insurance pay after an attack?
By David Freeland4 min read · 
One question on the renewal form
Your clinic’s cyber insurance renewal is due at the end of the week. One question asks, “Do you require MFA for all remote access to your network?”
MFA adds a second check after the password, such as a code your phone shows you. Your clinic email asks you for one. You check yes.
Later, you ask your office manager how she connects from home on Fridays to finish the billing. “My username and password,” she says. “That’s all it asks for.”
You answered honestly. But “all remote access” includes her connection. If an attack came in that way, your answer on that form could matter as much as the attack itself.
When the answer isn’t true
In 2022, an Illinois manufacturer called International Control Services (ICS) bought a cyber policy from Travelers. Its president signed a form saying MFA was required for email, remote access, and the company’s key systems. Weeks after the policy started, ransomware hit.
Travelers investigated and found MFA protected only the firewall, not the company’s servers. It refunded the premium and asked a federal court to cancel the policy. Both sides agreed, and the court declared the policy “null and void, from its inception.” In plain words, ICS was left with no coverage at all.
Think of telling your home insurer every room has a smoke detector when the basement doesn’t. If a fire starts in the basement, expect hard questions.
It isn’t only manufacturers. The insurer for California’s Cottage Health System paid a $4.1 million settlement after about 32,500 patient records were left open on the internet. In 2015, it sued to get the money back. It pointed to a clause excluding losses from failing to keep up the security practices described in the application.
Whether an insurer can refuse to pay depends on your policy and your state’s law. But a lawyer writing in September 2026 still pointed to the ICS case. An answer that overstates your security, the lawyer warned, “can place the policy at risk of rescission,” meaning canceled from the start.
What the form is really asking
Here’s one line from the MFA form on Travelers’ website. The signer confirms MFA is “required for all employees when accessing email through a website or cloud based service.”
Another line covers every remote connection into the network, including contractors and outside vendors. Notice the word “all.” Say one person on your team checks clinic email in a free webmail account with no MFA. Then that answer isn’t true. If an attack came in through that account, would the claim be paid? It would depend on the policy and the law. But it’s the same kind of gap Travelers found at ICS.
Claims data shows why insurers ask. At-Bay, another cyber insurer, studied its own claims from 2025 through early 2026. At-Bay also sells security services, and its report promotes them. That’s worth knowing, but it doesn’t shrink the risk. These numbers come from attacks that really happened.
- 30%of businesses with claims over four years thought MFA was on when it wasn’t.
- 60%of businesses At-Bay helped after an attack had no MFA, or used it on some systems but not all.
- 65%of the ransomware attacks At-Bay investigated, where the way in was known, came in through remote access.
- 53%of businesses At-Bay helped after an attack hadn’t turned on the email settings that make it harder for someone to send email pretending to be them. Those settings usually cost nothing extra.
Source: At-Bay, 2026 InsurSec Rankings: Email and Remote Access. At-Bay’s own claims and security data, 2025 through early 2026.
After a claim, the most common gap At-Bay found was staff who were set up for MFA but could still sign in without it. That’s the gap behind the renewal question. In ransom cases where paid attackers described their way in, nearly 60% said they had stolen the logins or bought them.
Closer to home: at Bakerford®, about 64% of the attacks we saw on our own customers in the year before this guide was published involved a stolen password.
Before you sign the renewal
- Answer from today, not the plan: If MFA is on most accounts but not all, say so. Travelers’ form asks you to explain any “no.” The 2026 lawyer’s advice: share your plan to finish instead of calling a partial rollout complete.
- Fill it out with your IT company: Go through each question together. Check every MFA answer against every account, including email, remote connections, and vendors who connect to your systems.
- Close the gaps you find: Make MFA required, with no way to skip it. Move clinic email off free accounts. Then ask your insurance agent what your policy says happens if an answer turns out wrong.
Do these, and the next time the renewal asks about MFA, you can check yes and know it’s true for every way in.
Disclaimer: This guide shares general information. It isn’t legal or insurance advice. For advice about your policy, talk with your insurance agent or a lawyer.
Last reviewed November 19, 2026.
References & statutory citations
- Insurance Journal: Travelers, Policyholder Agree to Void Current Cyber Policy (Chad Hemenway, August 30, 2022). The case: Travelers Property Casualty Co. of America v. International Control Services Inc., No. 22-cv-2145 (C.D. Ill.). (opens in a new tab)
- Farella Braun + Martel (JD Supra): Using Multi-Factor Authentication as a Prerequisite to Cyber Liability Coverage (August 12, 2022). (opens in a new tab)
- Business Insurance: Insurer Cites Cyber Policy Exclusion to Dispute Data Breach Settlement (May 15, 2015). The case: Columbia Casualty Co. v. Cottage Health System (C.D. Cal.). (opens in a new tab)
- Covington & Burling (Inside Privacy): Cyber Insurer Seeks to Void Data Breach Coverage Because of Purported Misstatements in Policy Application (June 16, 2016). (opens in a new tab)
- Shumaker, Loop & Kendrick (The National Law Review): Client Alert: The Tightening Gate: How Cyber Insurance Carriers Are Raising the Bar on Conditions Precedent to Coverage (Mark Lehman, September 29, 2026). (opens in a new tab)
- Travelers: Multi-Factor Authentication Supplement (form CYB-14306, Rev. 03-23), listed on Travelers’ CyberRisk applications page. (opens in a new tab)
- At-Bay: 2026 InsurSec Rankings: Email and Remote Access (pages 4–5, 22 and 25–29; claims from 2025 through the first quarter of 2026; October 2026; At-Bay’s own claims data. At-Bay sells cyber insurance and security services). (opens in a new tab)